Acuity vs Square Appointments: Which Is Better for a Small Business?
Acuity vs Square Appointments compared: free plan, prices, deposits, no-show fees, classes, payments and countries, checked on vendor sites 14 Oct 2026.

In the Acuity vs Square Appointments choice, pick Square Appointments if you’re a salon, barber or spa that takes card payments in person and wants a free plan with deposits. Pick Acuity Scheduling if you’re a coach, therapist, tutor or consultant who needs intake forms, packages and a choice of payment providers. Square only works in eight countries.
startbuddi is our product. It appears once, as a third option near the end. Prices and plan details come from each vendor’s own pricing page, checked on 14 October 2026.
Key takeaways
- Square Appointments has a free plan with online booking, unlimited staff calendars, deposits and text and email reminders. Acuity has no free plan, only a 7-day trial.
- Square charges per location: Plus is $49 a month and Premium $149. Acuity charges by number of calendars: $16, $27 or $49 a month billed yearly.
- Acuity takes payments through Stripe, Square, PayPal or Venmo. Square Appointments takes payments only through Square.
- No-show fees, waitlists, packages and classes need Square Plus, or Acuity Standard for waitlists, packages and memberships.
Acuity vs Square Appointments at a glance
| Acuity Scheduling | Square Appointments | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Appointment-based professionals: coaches, therapists, tutors | Salons, spas and barbers with a front desk |
| Free plan | No (7-day trial, no card) | Yes |
| Paid plans (US) | Starter $16, Standard $27, Premium $49 a month billed yearly ($20, $34, $61 monthly) | Plus $49, Premium $149 a month per location |
| Pricing unit | Calendars: 1, up to 6, up to 36 | Locations (unlimited staff calendars) |
| Payments | Stripe, Square, PayPal or Venmo | Square only |
| Deposits | Every plan | Every plan, including Free |
| Text reminders | Standard and Premium | Free and up |
| No-show fees | Through deposits and policies | Plus and Premium (card on file) |
| Waitlist | Standard and Premium | Plus and Premium |
| Packages and memberships | Standard and Premium | Class booking and packages on Plus and Premium |
| Intake forms | Every plan | Automatic contracts on every plan |
| Point of sale | Not the focus | Full Square POS and hardware |
| HIPAA | Signed BAA on Premium | Not listed on the pricing page |
| Countries | Plans priced in USD; depends on your payment provider | 8 countries for Square payments |
Sources: Acuity pricing and Square Appointments US pricing, checked on 14 October 2026. Prices exclude tax and card processing.
How Acuity and Square Appointments differ
Acuity Scheduling, part of Squarespace, grew up around the client who books a session: a coaching call, a massage, a tutoring hour. Its strengths are the intake form, the client record and selling time in bundles, such as a package of six sessions or a monthly membership. Payment is a step in the booking, through whichever provider you already use.
Square Appointments grew up around the counter. It’s part of Square’s point of sale, so the same system books the appointment, takes the card on a reader, sells a product and pays the stylist. Its strengths are the staff calendar, card on file and everything Square does with payments.
Verdict: decide where the money changes hands. Online before the session points to Acuity; at the counter points to Square.
Price: Square is cheaper to start, Acuity cheaper for some teams
Square’s free plan is a real starting point: online booking, unlimited staff calendars, deposits, prepayments, automatic contracts and reminders. You pay only when you take a card payment. Acuity has no free plan.
On paid plans, the units differ. Square charges per location, with unlimited staff. Acuity charges by calendars, which usually means staff or rooms.
| Illustrative month, billed yearly where offered | Acuity | Square Appointments |
|---|---|---|
| Solo therapist, needs text reminders | Standard: $27 | Free: $0 |
| Solo therapist, needs a waitlist | Standard: $27 | Plus: $49 |
| Four-person studio, one location, needs no-show fees | Standard: $27 (deposits and policies) | Plus: $49 |
| Ten stylists, one location | Premium: $49 (up to 36 calendars) | Plus: $49 |
| Two locations, three staff each | Standard: $27 (6 calendars) | Plus: 2 × $49 = $98 |
These are list prices, for illustration; Square’s prices are per location per month, and card processing comes on top of every option at the rates on each provider’s page.
Verdict: Square Free is unbeatable for a solo business in Square’s countries. With several locations, Acuity’s calendar-based price can work out lower.
No-shows: both protect you, in different ways
Square’s free plan takes deposits and prepayments and sends text and email reminders. From Plus you can set a cancellation window, require a card at booking and charge it for late cancellations or no-shows.
Acuity takes payments and deposits on every plan and sends email reminders from Starter. Text reminders and the waitlist start on Standard, and Acuity’s page asks you to check SMS availability for your country.
Verdict: Square, narrowly, because card-on-file no-show fees are a cleaner fix for a walk-in style business. For an online coach, Acuity’s upfront payment does the same job. Our guide on how much deposit to charge clients helps you set the amount.
Payments and where each works
This is the point that decides it for many readers.
Square Appointments only takes payments through Square. Square’s developer documentation lists card processing in eight countries: Australia, Canada, France, Ireland, Japan, Spain, the United Kingdom and the United States. Outside them, Square isn’t an option for card payments.
Acuity lets you connect Stripe, Square, PayPal or Venmo. That gives you more choice of provider and country, as long as one of them works where you are.
Verdict: Acuity, for flexibility. If you’re in Lagos, Nairobi or Accra, though, check whether any of those providers can pay out to you before you sign up for either.
Classes, packages and memberships
Acuity’s Standard plan lets you sell memberships, packages (including payment plans) and gift certificates, and Acuity runs class scheduling alongside one-to-one sessions. It’s a natural fit for a yoga teacher, a music tutor or a coach who sells blocks of sessions.
Square’s Plus plan adds class booking and packages: a prepaid series of services or classes, applied at checkout when redeemed, plus one-time or recurring group classes.
Verdict: Acuity for professionals who sell time in bundles online. Square for studios that sell classes over the counter as well as online.
Running the front desk
Square is the stronger front desk: unlimited staff calendars on every plan, multi-staff appointments and processing time on Plus, resource management (rooms and equipment) on Premium, plus the Square POS, card readers, text marketing and payroll as optional extras.
Acuity’s admin is lighter. It has a mobile admin app on every plan, multiple time zones for staff on Premium and a custom API and CSS on Premium, but it doesn’t try to be a till.
Verdict: Square for a busy salon or spa. Acuity for a practice where most clients book and pay online.
What the client sees when they book
The booking experience shapes how many people finish booking, so it’s worth looking at from the client’s side.
With Acuity, the client picks a service, sees times converted to their own time zone, fills in your intake form (details, terms and conditions, anything you need before the session) and pays if you require it. Online sessions get a Google Meet, Zoom or GoToMeeting link automatically. Premium adds an AI booking assistant, a chat bot that helps clients book.
With Square, the client books on your Square booking site, or through Instagram, Facebook or Google, which are listed on every plan. They can pay a deposit or the full price and sign an automatic contract on the free plan. From Plus they get confirmations, can join a waitlist, and can book one appointment that covers several services with different staff.
Verdict: Acuity for a booking that needs information up front. Square for a booking that needs to be quick and often happens on a phone from Instagram.
Calendars and staff
Square’s calendar is part of its point of sale. Every plan has unlimited staff calendars, colour coding by staff or service, and the option to block off personal time. Google Calendar sync and processing time (for example, colour developing while the stylist starts another client) come with Plus, and Premium adds resource management for rooms and equipment. If staff also keep personal appointments in Google Calendar, that sync is worth having before your first double booking.
Acuity’s calendars are its pricing unit: 1 on Starter, up to 6 on Standard, up to 36 on Premium, used per employee or per location. Premium lets each staff member or location keep its own time zone, which matters for a coaching team spread across London and Lagos.
Verdict: Square for a single busy floor; Acuity for a spread-out team of professionals. If you’re somewhere in between, count your staff and locations first, because that count sets the price on both.
Three examples
These are illustrative, to show how the choice usually falls.
- A barbershop in Manchester with five chairs. Clients book on Instagram, pay a deposit and settle at the counter by card. Square Appointments Free covers the bookings and deposits; Plus adds no-show fees and the waitlist for £29 a month.
- A business coach in Toronto who sells six-session packages. Clients book calls online and pay up front. Acuity Standard handles packages and text reminders; Square would need Plus for packages and is built around a counter she doesn’t have.
- A massage therapist in Nairobi. Square isn’t available in Kenya. Acuity works if Stripe or PayPal can pay out to her, and a tool that takes M-Pesa or bank transfer may suit her clients better.
Switching between Acuity and Square
Moving in either direction is mostly admin. Export your client list, recreate your services with their lengths and prices, set your availability, connect payments, then swap the booking link on Instagram, Google and your website. Leave the old tool running until existing bookings are done, so nobody turns up to a slot you’ve lost track of.
Choose Acuity Scheduling if…
- You’re a coach, therapist, tutor or consultant who books sessions.
- You want intake forms and to sell packages, memberships or gift certificates.
- You already use Stripe, PayPal or Venmo, or you’re outside Square’s countries.
- You need a signed BAA for HIPAA, on Premium.
Choose Square Appointments if…
- You’re a salon, barber or spa that takes cards in person.
- You want a free plan that already takes deposits and sends text reminders.
- You want point of sale, retail and payroll from the same company.
- You trade in one of Square’s eight countries.
A third option: startbuddi
If you’re outside Square’s countries and your clients pay by bank transfer, USSD or mobile money, both tools are a stretch. startbuddi Bookings lets clients book a service and pay the full price or a deposit before the booking is confirmed, through Paystack (card, bank transfer, USSD or mobile money) or Stripe, and each booking updates the client’s record alongside their WhatsApp messages and invoices. There’s a free plan with one live service; see pricing. It doesn’t do what either tool does best: no point of sale or card reader like Square, and no packages, memberships or gift certificates like Acuity. Calendar sync is one way, and there are no recurring bookings. See startbuddi vs Acuity and startbuddi vs Square Appointments for detail, or try startbuddi Bookings free.
For salons in particular, our salon appointment software list covers more options; for coaches, see booking software for coaches. The best booking software list and Setmore alternatives cover the wider field.
Frequently asked questions
Is Acuity or Square Appointments better?
Square Appointments is better for salons, spas and barbers that take card payments in person, especially on a budget, because its free plan takes deposits and sends reminders. Acuity is better for coaches, therapists and consultants who need intake forms, packages and a choice of payment providers.
Does Acuity Scheduling have a free plan?
No. Acuity's pricing page says it doesn't offer free scheduling, but every plan has a 7-day trial with no credit card. Starter costs $16 a month billed yearly or $20 monthly.
Is Square Appointments free?
Yes. Square Appointments Free costs $0 a month and includes online booking, unlimited staff calendars, deposits and text and email reminders. You pay processing fees when you take a payment. No-show fees, the waitlist and Google Calendar sync need Plus, at $49 a month per location in the US.
Can Acuity use Square for payments?
Yes. Acuity lists Square as one of its payment options, alongside Stripe, PayPal and Venmo. So a business that already takes cards on Square can still use Acuity's forms and packages.
Which is better for a salon, Acuity or Square?
For most salons, Square Appointments, because it combines staff calendars, card-on-file no-show fees and point of sale. Acuity can work for a solo stylist who takes payment online, but it isn't built around a front desk.
Do Acuity and Square Appointments work in Nigeria?
Square Appointments doesn't, because Square processes payments in only eight countries, none in Africa. Acuity sells its plans online in US dollars, but it takes payments only through Stripe, Square, PayPal or Venmo, so check which of those can pay out to you before relying on it for deposits.
Tiwalade Joanna Okedara-Kalu is the founder, CEO and CTO of startbuddi, the business system that brings clients, bookings, invoices, projects, marketing and the Chip AI assistant into one place. Tiwalade builds software around how service businesses really work day to day, and writes about client management, getting paid on time and why small businesses outgrow the tools they start with.
Founded startbuddi and leads its product and engineering




